That is possible, although I seem to remember reproducing it in my own deck when I cast Energy Ray with my own BH in play. I was thinking the issue would be that two counters are being simultaneously removed by one spell on the stack only able to remove one. I will see if I can reproduce it.Psyringe wrote: I haven't checked the program code for counters, but judging from the card code, I'd say that this is very unlikely to happen this way. Are you sure that there weren't any other bonuses involved? The R/W AI deck with Belligerent Hatchling also has Balefire Liege, which will give Belligerent Hatchling a +2/+2 bonus. Some days ago we got a bug report about Voracious Hatchling becoming too strong, but it turned out that the person who submitted the bug report had overlooked the Deathbringer Liege which also gave the Hatchling a bonus, and he misinterpreted this correct bonus as bug with counter removal. Could this have happened to you too?
I will eagerly await the next release with a fixed scourglass. I love that card. Thanks for the quick reply!